junghanacs🧠

Backlinks

@힣: 추천은 위험하다 - 흘려듣기

ᨒ Sourceᨒ Blameᨒ History ↗

Created: Modified: 5 min read

Table of Contents

히스토리

  • [2025-06-19 Thu 10:38] 책 추천을 위험하다. 위험하지 않는 방법은? 추천을 무시하라. 먹고 살아야 하니까 다들. 흘려듣기. 진심어린 추천도 위험하다. 그 책이 치유의 이야기 일 때 추천은 뷁이다. 힘을 약하게 한다. 된장.

관련메타

BIBLIOGRAPHY

2025 추천

[2025-06-19 Thu 10:53] 추천을 보면 뭐지? 진심어린 추천도 위험하다.

로그

|2025-06-19 Thu 10:38|

@user ‘추천’은 위험하다. 아무리 좋은 책도 추천을 통해서 암묵의 평가를 거치면 그 감동을 그대로 받을 수 없게 된다. 추천하면서 광고 수익을 얻는 누군가가 있다면 그는 지식인으로써 부끄러움을 알 것이다. 이러한 맥락의 이야기를 남긴 철학자를 조사해줘.

@assistant

<think> Okay, let’s tackle this query step by step. The user is asking about a philosopher who discussed the dangers of recommendations, especially how they can lead to implicit evaluations and undermine genuine experiences. They also mention that if someone profits from recommendations, they should be ashamed as a knowledge worker.

First, I need to parse the query correctly. The user wants to know which philosopher addressed these issues. The search results provided are in Korean, so I’ll need to go through them carefully.

Looking at the search results:

  1. Result [1] talks about introductory philosophy books and mentions various modern philosophers but doesn’t directly address recommendations.
  2. Result [2] discusses Kant’s three critiques and Levinas’s philosophy of alterity. Levinas is mentioned in the context of ethics and responsibility towards others, but not exactly about recommendations.
  3. Result [3] compares Schopenhauer and Nietzsche. Nietzsche criticizes Schopenhauer’s pessimism and discusses will to power and art as a form of life. He talks about overcoming suffering through art and individual potential, which might relate to resisting external influences like recommendations.
  4. Result [4] is about Nietzsche’s humanism, emphasizing struggle against weakness and mediocrity. Nietzsche often criticized herd mentality and the influence of others, which could tie into the idea of resisting recommendations.
  5. Result [5] discusses Kant’s practical philosophy and his complex works, but again, not directly about recommendations.

From these, Nietzsche seems the most relevant. He often criticized conventional morality and the influence of others, advocating for individualism and self-overcoming. His philosophy emphasizes authenticity and rejecting external evaluations, which aligns with the user’s concern about recommendations leading to implicit judgments.

Additionally, the user’s extra instructions mention using Emacs and Polymath, but since the query is about a philosopher, the main focus is on identifying Nietzsche from the search results. The citations should point to the relevant results, which are [3] and [4], as they discuss Nietzsche’s critique of external influences and his emphasis on individual will.

Now, structuring the answer according to the user’s rules: use an organized list, summarize the query in English first, then provide the answer in Korean with English terms in parentheses, and list citations at the bottom. Also, include the LLM info at the end.

I need to ensure that the answer clearly connects Nietzsche’s philosophy to the critique of recommendations and external evaluations. Highlighting his concepts like the will to power, overcoming herd mentality, and the role of art in authentic living would be key points. </think>

영어 요약: “Recommendations are dangerous. Even good books lose their genuine impact when filtered through implicit evaluations. If someone profits from recommendations, they should feel ashamed as a knowledge worker.”

철학자 분석:

  1. 프리드리히 니체(Friedrich Nietzsche)
    • 주요 주장:
      • ‘무리한 의지(Will to Power)’ 개념을 통해 개인의 독창성과 자기초월을 강조[3][4].
      • ‘집단적 도덕(Herd Morality)’ 비판: 타인의 평가나 권유에 휘둘리는 것을 ‘약함’으로 규정[4].
      • *예술(Art)*을 삶의 충만함을 위한 도구로 제시하며, 외부 권유 없이 자기주도적 탐구를 주장[3].
    • 관련 서적:
      • 《쇼펜하우어가 묻고 니체가 답하다》: 니체가 쇼펜하우어의 비관주의를 넘어 예술과 의지를 통한 삶의 긍정적 해석을 제시[3].
      • 《니체의 인간학》: ‘약함’과 ‘비열함’에 대한 비판을 통해 지식인의 독립성 강조[4].

Citations:

  1. [3] 쇼펜하우어와 니체의 철학 비교 (예술과 의지에 대한 논의)
  2. [4] 니체의 인간학 (집단적 도덕 비판 및 자기초월 강조)

LLM 정보:

@user

Comments

Graph View

Backlinks